License #: 1083225

Shingle vs. Tile Roofs: Which One is Right for Your Home?

In Southern California, most homes and residential buildings feature roofs made of shingles or tiles, each material lending a distinct aesthetic and impacting the property’s curb appeal. If you’re considering building a new home or replacing your current roof, it’s essential to understand the unique properties of these roofing materials. Factors such as cost, durability, energy efficiency, and aesthetics play a critical role. By exploring the features, benefits, and drawbacks of both shingles and tiles, you can choose the roofing material that best suits your needs.

All About Shingle Roofs

Shingle roofs are among the most common roof types in the United States. As many as 70% of residential buildings nationwide feature asphalt shingle roofs. The primary roofing material of a shingle roof is the asphalt shingle. This material is known for its durability, effectiveness in nearly any environment and season, and relatively low cost. These properties are why asphalt shingle roofs are popular in all 50 states, from southern California to northern Maine. The average cost of a shingle roof in California ranges from $0.60 to $2.33 per square foot, making it one of the cheaper options for roofing projects. However, the exact price for your home depends on the size of your roof, the brand and type of shingle used, and any labor costs. For example, higher-quality shingles may have been tested and rated for fire, wind, uplift, and impact resistance, increasing the cost per square foot. If you are replacing an old roof with new materials, your project may also include the costs of removing old tile and inspecting the roof’s underpinnings. A professional roofing contractor can assess the dimensions and complexity of your roof and provide you with an accurate quote of the project’s cost.

Overview of Tile Roofs

Tile roofs, while not as widespread nationwide, are frequently seen across Los Angeles and southern California. Tile roofing is a durable and aesthetically pleasing solution for most residences in the state. The average cost of a tile roof depends on the material used, ranging from as low as $2 per square foot to as high as $25. The two most common materials for California roofs are clay and concrete. Each of these materials is available in different shapes, colors, and styles, affecting their properties and price per square foot.
  • Clay tiles. These tiles are the best solution for maximizing a home’s curb appeal and giving it a unique appearance. The price per square foot ranges from $12 per square foot for simpler, unglazed tile up to $25 for specially shaped and fire-glazed tile.
  • Concrete tiles. Although concrete roofs are more commonly associated with commercial buildings, they can also be an excellent fit for a home due to their durability and cost-effectiveness. The average price per square foot ranges from $2 to $4. While they cannot be formed into as many different shapes as clay tiles, concrete tiles are available in an extensive range of sizes. They can also be painted in a virtually unlimited range of colors to match your home.

Shingle Roofs vs. Tile Roofs Compared

To determine if shingles or tiles are the best choice for your roof, it’s essential to compare the characteristics of each material. Here’s an overview of the key factors to consider:
Factor Shingles Tiles
Cost-effectiveness
  • Typically more cost-efficient.
  • An average 1,500-square-foot roof costs about $1,200 to $1,500 in materials with standard 3-tab shingles.
  • Higher-quality architectural shingles can cost up to $4,500 in materials.
  • Typically more expensive. 
  • An average 1,500-square-foot roof requires between $18,000 and $37,500 of clay tiles, depending on shape and quality.
  • Concrete tiles tend to be lower priced than clay, usually requiring $3,000 to $6,000 in materials.
Ease of installation
  • Shingles are lighter and easier to install, reducing labor costs and total project times.
  • Tiles are heavier, and certain materials require more careful handling. 
  • They must also be installed on a properly reinforced roof, increasing project length and labor costs.
Longevity
  • Standard shingles last for up to 10-20 years with professional installation and adequate maintenance. 
  • Premium shingle materials, such as architectural or highly-rated shingles, can last for up to 40 years.
  • Typical clay tile roofs can last up to 100 years, making them the best choice for maximum durability and longevity.
  • Concrete tiles are less durable than tile but can last up to 50 years, longer than most shingles.
Thermal efficiency
  • Higher heat absorption rates, meaning it attracts and transfers more heat into the home than tile. 
  • Typically better suited in colder regions.
  • Excellent heat reflection properties, making them ideal for saving energy on air conditioning during the summer and meeting California Cool Roof requirements.
Aesthetics
  • While different grades and styles of asphalt shingles are available, most aesthetic options are relatively limited.
  • Both clay and concrete tiles are available in a wide range of materials, colors, shapes, and styles to fit nearly any architectural style.

Select the Best Roofing Material Today

The best roofing materials for your home depend on your budget, the type and size of your roof, durability and longevity needs, and your home’s aesthetic needs. If you are uncertain whether tiles, shingles, or another roofing material would best fit your roofing project, contact an experienced roofing contractor in your area. They can assess your house’s size, the specifics of your roof’s dimensions and complexity, and help you find the best roofing materials for your home.  

FAQs

Yes. However, you should contact a professional roofing contractor to have your roof evaluated for suitability. Because tiles are heavier, a roof previously built for asphalt shingles may not have the reinforcing needed to support the extra weight. Contractors can include roof reinforcement in their quote, giving you an accurate estimate of the project’s total costs.

Clay tiles are the most durable roofing materials. With proper maintenance, a clay tile roof can last up to 100 years, making it an excellent choice to preserve your home’s value in the long term. While concrete tiles don’t have the same longevity, their denser composition makes them more resistant to extreme conditions, such as hail, fire, and wind.

Asphalt shingle roofs are preferred by many homeowners in California and nationwide because they are more affordable and require less time to install or replace. If your house’s roof has a high slope angle, the lower weight of asphalt shingles can be an additional benefit; they will put less stress on the underpinnings than heavier clay or concrete tiles.

Tile roofs, especially long-lasting clay tiles, are generally easier to maintain in the long run. Inspections and maintenance typically only require checking for cracked or broken tiles, which can be individually replaced without disturbing the remaining tiles.

Asphalt shingles must be inspected more often and cleaned to prevent debris accumulation and moss or algae formation. While individual shingles are less likely to crack or be damaged by the elements, improper maintenance can accelerate wear and tear, resulting in costly repairs.

Like this article?

Share on Facebook
Share on Twitter
Share on Linkdin
Share on Pinterest

Leave a comment